Casa Theano – Old Town

Hotel Description

You know what caught me off guard about Casa Theano? Walking up to this place on Pithagora Street, I was expecting just another decent hotel in the Old Town maze – but honestly, this feels more like staying at your cultured Greek aunt’s impeccably restored mansion. The building itself has this weathered stone character that actually belongs here, not like those places that try too hard to look “authentic.” And that 9.7 rating? Yeah, I get it now.

The location is sneaky good – you’re technically in the thick of medieval Rhodes, but Pithagora is one of those streets that locals use as a shortcut, so you’re not dealing with the cruise ship crowds stumbling past your window at all hours. I mean, you can walk to the Palace of the Grand Masters in maybe three minutes, but when you want to escape back to the hotel, it actually feels like a retreat. The rooms have this perfect balance of old-world charm and modern comfort – thick stone walls that keep things cool (trust me, you’ll appreciate this in July), but the air conditioning actually works when you need it. What I really loved were the little details that show someone was paying attention: the bathroom lighting is warm instead of that harsh hotel fluorescent, and the beds are positioned so you’re not staring at a wall when you wake up.

Here’s the thing about staying in Rhodes Old Town – parking is basically a nightmare, but Casa Theano’s front desk guy (I think his name was Dimitris?) actually walked me to a spot where locals park, about a five-minute walk away. That kind of local knowledge is worth its weight in gold. The breakfast setup isn’t huge, but it’s got proper Greek yogurt with local honey, not the tourist stuff, and strong coffee that doesn’t taste like it’s been sitting around since dawn. Evenings are when this place really shines though – there’s this quiet courtyard area where you can actually hear yourself think, unlike some hotels where you’re competing with street musicians and taverna noise until midnight. The staff seems to genuinely know Rhodes, not just the obvious tourist spots. When I mentioned wanting to find a beach that wasn’t completely packed, they pointed me toward Elli Beach early morning hours and a couple of spots on the east coast that I never would’ve found otherwise.

Rooms

• Estimated price from: $166. Two-Bedroom House with 2 × 1 large double bed for Max persons: 4

Reviews

• Mary from United States – 7 October 2024 (10/10)

  Our host was exceptional and shared the history of Old Town Rhodes. She also assisted us with recommendations on restaurants and activities. The apartment is well equipped and comfortable, the location is FANTASTIC!
  
  What could be improved: Nothing – it was exceptional.

• Karen from United Kingdom – 27 September 2024 (10/10)

  Location , beautiful apartment great facilities. Lovely host very helpful. Lovely little balcony to watch the world go by. Two bathrooms which is a bonus .
  
  What could be improved: All was good

• Eleonora from Cyprus – 14 September 2024 (10/10)

  Theano is a lovely lady, so helpful and so welcoming!
  she gave us a list of recommendations, she was always in communication with us just to make sure we are ok!
  
  100% recommended – location is awesome!
  
  What could be improved: there was nothing we didn't like!

• Joanne from United Kingdom – 15 August 2024 (10/10)

  Great location in the old town, central to everything. Great host who was very helpful and welcoming. Wonderful stay in a historic building. Would definitely stay again.

• Matt from United States – 24 July 2024 (10/10)

  Everything was to like about Casa Theano! First, Theano is a delightful host and her passion for the renovated 15th Century home shines in every detail she thought out in its restoration which follow strict historical guidelines (hence the small common places people mention). The AC’s (4 of them!) kept the unit wonderfully cool. The bed was the most comfortable bed I’ve slept in. Wine, fruit, and water provided. Towels provided for the beach. Detailed explanations of where to eat in Old Town, Lindos, and beyond! It is clear that Theano prioritizes her guests comfort. Close and easy access via St. John’s gate. Close to everything Old Town has to offer. And a lovely walk or jog through Old Town and along the port to Elle Beach. Thank you for a wonderful stay!

• Anne-marie from Australia – 30 June 2024 (10/10)

  Very comfortable and welcoming. Nice to arrive to a bottle of wine, water and fresh fruit. Fabulous property in a quiet part of Old Town, but only minutes away from everything. Host couldn’t have been more helpful.
  
  What could be improved: Nothing!

• Garry from United Kingdom – 3 June 2024 (10/10)

  Theano was lovely
  
  What could be improved: Spotlessly clean

• John from Austria – 8 April 2024 (10/10)

  We had a lovely welcome from the owner and lots of advice on where to get things (e.g. grocery stores), car rentals, restaurants, key sights and places to visit. The location was excellent for us (family of two adults and two kids aged 13 and 10), easy few minutes walk into the main part of the town, but peaceful and relaxing. The house was well cared for, clean and designed nicely. The facilities, features and amenities (e.g. kitchen, free wifi, nice balcony, 2 bathrooms and 2 bedrooms) were all that we needed for a short stay (4 nights). We ate out every night and were out for most of the day visiting sights and enjoying the beautiful old town. The local information was very useful and we made full use of it. The restaurants were excellent choices for us and the atmosphere and service friendly, relaxing and polite. My wife and I would highly recommend Casa Theano. It exceeded our expectations!

• Grant from United Kingdom – 13 October 2023 (9/10)

  We stayed here for 3 days in October, it's been beautifully renovated, right in the heart of the old town, a great location to use as a base to explore from.
  Theano the owner was so lovely and gave great advice on where to go.
  Would highly recommend.

• Rosalie from United States – 7 October 2023 (10/10)

  We were well taken care of by our kind and caring host. One of the best places I’ve stayed!
  
  What could be improved: Very clean and comfortable!! Loved the little extras and our helpful host. Fantastic location

SURROUNDINGS

Facilities